Notes From a Publisher: AFP - Miss a Day, Miss a Lot

Wow. What a day. Being a modern publisher sure isn't easy work - especially since I'm not really doing it full time. Yes, I do a lot of freelancing to pay the bills. Anyway, I feel bad for not being at the school board meeting tonight. I thought about it, but the work involved was a lot - to do a video and what-not. (And yet here I am wasting time writing a blog post, right?) Some days it seems like you can never win or get ahead.
I believe in what I'm doing, or trying to do, though. And that makes it all a little bit easier. I really felt a need to stop what happened earlier and sit down and write something out trying to explain. I guess maybe CC-Gal got me to thinking that I handled it the wrong way. I don't see removing that as back pedaling, though. Because AFP is a thriving, living organism - you miss a day, you miss a lot.
And you guys - the people FORMERLY known as the audience, the readers - you're what makes it tick. Don't think for a moment that I don't realize that. And I guess I'm really open here on the site - personally even. And that's one of the reasons AFP (imho) offers so much more value (for the money) than the HB currently does.
Ok, let's talk about the content you post here. If you read most agreements for the large sites (Gannett, etc.), once you post, the companies pretty much own them lock stock and barrel. There are no ways to delete. That's right. I was very, very liberal with the ability to delete content here at AFP. (And it burned me, I guess. Live and learn.) The big corporations, though, the other websites, they have agreements that state they own your content after you post it.
I want to know what you guys think. Nothing at AFP is written in stone at the moment when it comes to this. Remember, though, that most other sites don't even make this a consideration. You may be able to delete the account, but the content you created with it stays.
So, if you want the ability to delete everything you've posted here at AFP (take your ball and go home), I'll need to take time to program a neat/clean way to do this WITHOUT losing a lot of data from other members at AFP - all out conversations are weaved together. I shoulda given people the ability to EDIT their own posts, but not DELETE them. Lesson learned. It was a zinger, too.
Seriously, though, let's have a discussion about this. Say someone says they want all their content deleted, the button is pressed and they're wiped from AFP's history, then the next day they change their mind. What then?
To be honest, I'm leaning toward going with most other online publishers in saying that once it's here it's here - or maybe you can edit the comments out one by one, but not delete them along with other comments/threads/memes/etc. Sigh. The Internets are so complicated these days. Smile. That's one reason I love my job, though.
And you guys - the people here. You make me mad, you make me happy, you make me sad, you make me feel the whole range of human emotions. And that's a wonderful think. Thanks for letting me be part of that process.
The decision is going to come down to me, of course, but I want to open up the discussion about the content you post here at AFP. Should I make it like other mainstream sites or a little looser?
Please be respectful in this thread and limit it to the discussion at hand.
Thanks.
- kpaul.mallasch's blog
- Login or register to post comments
- Printer-friendly version
- 678 reads



Here's what AFP has for the Terms of Service currently...
If I had the "Magic Jeanie Lamp"
I would rub it Make my wishes as...
1.Only allow started forum content to be deleted/removed by your authority..
2.Editing of their forum posts is something different, allow the user that..
3.If a user wants to leave.. they can leave their content, unless..
"Not lazy enough" to go through, one by one to delete them..
OK, 3 wishes over..here your lamp back Kpaul..
T_M
It is not length of life, but depth of life.
Ralph Waldo Emerson
How a Man plays the game shows something of his character
How he loses shows all of it..
I also would like to be able to edit posts.
I also think that if you want to leave the forum...your posts should stay. That way a thread would make more sense. if you allow someone to delete all their posts, then threads are going to be hard to follow.
What?? You can't understand what I am saying? I am speaking plain penguin!!
I have to agree with Zia, I think the edit thing has been asked before.
Once again....I liked the way HB had it. If you are the original poster, once someone has responded you can only edit your content, not delete it. Otherwise, I like the idea of deleting your own posts. If you want to keep things in context, quote what you are responding to, then if they delete, it's saved for posterity. ;)
Posters should have the ability to edit their own posts. I've had to edit mine many times and it would really bug me if I couldn't do that.
Besides, editing gives each poster the ability to virtually delete the content of each of their posts without deleting the post per se, although it would force them to go through each thread post-by-post to delete all of their content, if that was their intent.
I like CC's idea about quoting the post you're responding to, just to make sure there is continuity in the thread.
“If you treat an individual as he is, he will stay as he is; but if you treat him as if he were what he ought to be and could be, he will become what he ought to be and could be.” ~ Johann Wolfgang von Goethe
I'll see what I can do to implement editing w/out deleting. Thanks.
Wait a minute, I know that the HB actually deleted some threads, how did that happen?
Well, I would still be able to delete or unpublish them, but I meant a way for you guys to be able to edit a forum or blog without deleting all the comments that go along with it.
You mean that you could delete a thread, like (and maybe they are different) the story that appears twice that you just did about Pence congrats someone from New Castle.